Bitwise’s Zcash ETF Bid Adds an In-Kind Challenge to Grayscale
• November 19, 2026 4:03 pm • CommentsBitwise is trying to make the next Zcash exchange-traded fund work differently from the one already on the market.
The distinction reaches into the plumbing of how professional trading firms create and redeem ETF shares—and whether those firms can receive ZEC directly instead of waiting for a cash settlement.
According to CryptoSlate, Bitwise’s November 17 filing proposes an ETF that could let authorized participants redeem 10,000-share baskets for either cash or ZEC. The proposed fund would trade on the Texas Stock Exchange under the ticker ZEC if it clears the remaining regulatory and operational hurdles.
The filing puts that flexibility against Grayscale’s existing ZCSH product, where authorized participants receive cash on redemption. A separate liquidity provider takes ZEC from the trust and supplies the money for the payout.
That difference could affect the cost and speed of arbitrage when ETF shares drift away from the value of the underlying ZEC. It could also make Bitwise more dependent on firms that can safely custody, hedge and sell a privacy-focused asset during volatile markets.
The redemption route is the real competitive difference
Authorized participants are the large financial firms that help keep an ETF’s market price close to the value of the assets it holds. When an ETF trades at a discount, those firms can buy shares, redeem a large basket and capture the difference—provided the redemption process is efficient enough.
Bitwise’s preliminary S-1 says an in-kind redemption could send ZEC to a wallet selected by the authorized participant or its designee. The filing also leaves room for cash settlement, so the direct ZEC route is a proposed capability rather than a guarantee for every redemption.
Grayscale’s Zcash ETF takes a different path. Its quarterly filing describes cash redemptions for authorized participants.
A liquidity provider receives the ZEC from the trust and supplies the cash that ultimately goes back to the redeeming firm.
Both structures can support arbitrage. Bitwise’s proposal would remove one intermediary when an authorized participant can receive and manage ZEC directly.
That could give a trading desk more control over execution, hedging and timing. It also makes the quality of ZEC market liquidity more important during a sharp move.
Zcash’s privacy thesis is colliding with institutional constraints
Bitwise CIO Matt Hougan has argued that privacy could become more valuable as Bitcoin is absorbed into traditional financial products. In his view, some longtime crypto holders may eventually look beyond Bitcoin for an asset that preserves more of crypto’s original privacy promise.
Bitwise CIO Matt Hougan sees a potential $BTC to $ZEC rotation this cycle, as institutions absorb Bitcoin and OG holders seek privacy
"Privacy is an important part of the ecosystem. And as traditional assets get smushed into the institutional world, they lose an element of… pic.twitter.com/bnAau9TXHy
— Laura Shin (@laurashin) November 14, 2026
There is an obvious tension in that pitch: the proposed ETF would not use Zcash’s shielded transactions. Its wallets would use transparent addresses, and professional firms handling direct ZEC redemptions would still operate inside conventional compliance systems.
That does not make the privacy thesis meaningless. It does show that institutional exposure to a privacy-focused network is not the same thing as using that network’s strongest privacy features.
The regulatory risk is unusually concrete. The filing notes that exchanges have restricted ZEC in some markets, while European anti-money-laundering rules scheduled for 2027 could limit how regulated providers interact with anonymizing accounts.
Less exchange access can mean thinner liquidity, wider spreads and more difficult in-kind redemptions.
Grayscale already proved there is institutional demand
Bitwise is entering an established category. Grayscale’s ZCSH has grown into a meaningful product, and its share count rose sharply after listing.
CoinDesk’s November Zcash review put the fund’s assets at $724 million as of October 31, before the more recent redemptions described in Grayscale’s quarterly disclosures.
Grayscale’s Zcash ETF (ZCSH) saw its share count rise 54.2% from Aug. 25 to Oct. 30. With $724M in assets as of Oct. 31, ZCSH became Grayscale’s largest single-asset ETF outside its Bitcoin and Ether funds, surpassing its Hyperliquid and Solana funds.
Read more:… pic.twitter.com/oGaZdByeyU
— CoinDesk (@CoinDesk) November 6, 2026
Bitwise is challenging Grayscale on the mechanics that determine share-price alignment and liquidity. The test is whether a more flexible creation-and-redemption design can work without running into the market-access limits that have followed Zcash for years.
If Bitwise wins approval, investors should watch three things: whether in-kind redemptions are available at launch, which firms are willing and able to receive ZEC, and whether the new fund actually trades closer to net asset value than ZCSH. Those details will matter more than the ticker.
Join the conversation!
We have no tolerance for comments containing violence, racism, profanity, vulgarity, doxing, or discourteous behavior. If a comment is spam, instead of replying to it please click the icon below and to the right of that comment. Thank you for partnering with us to maintain fruitful conversation.
