Physicist in a quantum information laboratory

SHRINCS Gives Bitcoin a Post-Quantum Path—But the Block-Space Cost Is Huge

• November 19, 2026 7:27 pm • Comments

Bitcoin’s post-quantum debate is moving from a distant thought experiment toward an engineering decision with real costs.

A proposal called SHRINCS is emerging as a serious candidate because it relies on SHA-256, the same battle-tested hash function already embedded throughout Bitcoin. That conservative foundation is attractive.

The hard part is making the new signatures safe for ordinary users without consuming too much block space.

Decrypt reported that Blockstream Research Director Jonas Nick, researcher Mikhail Kudinov, and other collaborators released a security analysis of SHRINCS while asking engineers, cryptographers, and protocol developers to pressure-test the design.

The proposal combines two spending paths. A stateful path produces smaller, more efficient signatures.

A stateless fallback is safer from an implementation perspective, but its signatures are much larger.

The analysis frames SHRINCS as an emerging contender, not a finished network upgrade. Its draft specification still needs review from wallet developers, protocol engineers, and cryptographers before Bitcoin stakeholders can judge whether the safety and efficiency tradeoffs are acceptable in real-world use, whether wallets can enforce the state rules reliably, and whether large signatures would place too much pressure on fees and block capacity.

That review process is now underway.

The stateful option carries a dangerous failure mode. It depends on one-time keys that must never be reused.

If a wallet mishandles that state and signs twice with the same one-time material, an attacker could potentially forge a signature and steal funds from the address.

That means wallet software cannot leave the safety decision to a user clicking the right button. Implementations would need to track state correctly and automatically force the stateless fallback whenever there is any doubt about whether the one-time state remains secure.

The fallback solves one problem by creating another. Bitcoin’s Taproot Schnorr signatures are 64 bytes.

SHRINCS’ stateful signatures range from 548 to 4,619 bytes, while the stateless version is 5,777 bytes. Even the smallest option is many times larger than what Bitcoin uses today.

Those numbers matter because block space is scarce. If wallets routinely default to the stateless path, fewer transactions would fit into each block.

That could increase fees and reduce the number of people able to use the network during busy periods.

SHRINCS is not a finished Bitcoin upgrade, and the researchers are not presenting it as one. The current work is about proving the cryptographic foundation, refining the draft Bitcoin Improvement Proposal, and exposing design weaknesses before the ecosystem commits to a path.

That caution is exactly what Bitcoin needs. Quantum-resistant signatures cannot merely survive an attack on paper.

They also have to survive imperfect wallet code, user mistakes, fee spikes, and the unforgiving economics of a fixed block-size system.

SHRINCS now has a credible place in that conversation. Whether it becomes Bitcoin’s answer will depend on whether researchers can preserve its conservative security assumptions while shrinking the very large operational cost.

Join the conversation!

We have no tolerance for comments containing violence, racism, profanity, vulgarity, doxing, or discourteous behavior. If a comment is spam, instead of replying to it please click the icon below and to the right of that comment. Thank you for partnering with us to maintain fruitful conversation.